For a hypothetical $10,000 debt payoff with a 3% fee withheld from the new loan, gross principal must be $10,309.28. At an 18% annual note interest rate over 36 months, the modeled payment is $372.71. Compare the full scheduled repayment and net payoff amount as well as the payment; these figures are not lender offers.
Why a $10,000 headline amount may not pay off $10,000
A fee withheld from gross principal reduces the money available for creditors. A $10,000 gross loan with a 3% fee leaves $9,700, creating a $300 shortfall. To hold net payoff proceeds at $10,000, this model uses P = 10000 / (1 - 0.03) = 10309.2783505.... The $309.28 fee is financed within that principal; it is not added a second time to scheduled repayments. Actual payoff quotes and lender rounding can require a different final amount.
How do rate and term change the payment?
Each row below funds the same $10,000 payoff. Assumptions: fixed annual note interest, equal monthly periods, 3% withheld fee, no other charges or new borrowing, on-time payments, and no daily-accrual adjustments. The note rates are invented scenario inputs, not current market averages or fee-inclusive APRs. Financing cost is scheduled repayments minus $10,000 net payoff proceeds.
| Annual note rate | Months | Gross principal | Monthly payment | Scheduled repayments | Financing cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12% | 24 | $10,309.28 | $485.29 | $11,647.04 | $1,647.04 |
| 12% | 36 | $10,309.28 | $342.42 | $12,326.96 | $2,326.96 |
| 12% | 60 | $10,309.28 | $229.32 | $13,759.45 | $3,759.45 |
| 18% | 24 | $10,309.28 | $514.68 | $12,352.36 | $2,352.36 |
| 18% | 36 | $10,309.28 | $372.71 | $13,417.38 | $3,417.38 |
| 18% | 60 | $10,309.28 | $261.79 | $15,707.27 | $5,707.27 |
| 24% | 24 | $10,309.28 | $545.06 | $13,081.51 | $3,081.51 |
| 24% | 36 | $10,309.28 | $404.46 | $14,560.65 | $4,560.65 |
| 24% | 60 | $10,309.28 | $296.58 | $17,794.62 | $7,794.62 |
Does the lower payment save money?
At the same illustrative 18% note rate, extending 36 months to 60 months reduces the payment from $372.71 to $261.79, while increasing scheduled repayments by $2,289.89. That is payment relief with a longer obligation, not demonstrated savings against the old debts.
Before replacing the debt, calculate what the current accounts would cost under a realistic payment plan. The same-budget payoff comparison holds monthly payment capacity constant. The separate 216-scenario dataset explores different balances, fixed current payments, fees and terms; it is not the source of the nine rows above.
How can you reproduce any row?
Use r = annual note rate / 1200, M = P*r / (1 - (1+r)^(-n)), repayments = M*n and financing cost = repayments - net proceeds. At zero interest use M=P/n. Retain full precision until displaying cents; multiplying the displayed rounded payment may differ by a few cents. Real contracts may adjust the last installment. Ask for the actual APR, payment schedule and fee treatment in the written offer.
What belongs in your own payment worksheet?
- Obtain current payoff figures and their valid-through dates for each debt.
- Record gross principal, withheld or separately paid fees, and net proceeds.
- Check the required payment against a weaker-income month after essentials.
- Compare the old-debt and new-loan schedules, including the final payment.
- Confirm completed creditor payoffs and avoid rebuilding paid-off balances.
Use the payoff documentation matrix, cash-flow stress test and written-offer guide. The CFPB consolidation guidance explains why a smaller payment or replacing debts does not alone establish an improvement.
Sources supporting this explanation
- CFPB: consolidation alternatives, fees, repayment length and the risk of rebuilding card balances
- CFPB: annual note interest differs from APR that includes applicable loan costs
Sources checked 2026-10-29. Examples are hypothetical BYL calculations or planning worksheets;they are not observed lender prices,offers or approval criteria.